Tel: (845) 626-2627   Home   Contact  
Sun Volt

Sun Volt Solar

earth, the final frontier

Clean Energy, Clean Environment

We are at a cross roads in human history, we can choose to continue on as we have been, or we can make a change to improve our future and quite possibly the future for several generations to come. We are here to promote energy independence, a better environment, a secure future and a higher return on investment for your hard earned dollar. It is what I believe in, it is why I am in the solar business.

Ground Source Heat Pump; same as a coal stove?

03 Jan 09 | Conservation, Environment, Geothermal

I read a lot of information on a daily basis.  A few months ago, somebody commented that a Ground Source Geothermal Heat Pump is the same as using a coal stove to heat your house.  The notion is that by purchasing and installing a GSHP, a homeowner is only pushing the problem further away (to the electrical generation plant), not actually reducing pollution.

Is that right?  Perhaps a little research is in order.

First, a little background.  A Ground Source Heat Pump (GSHP) uses a refrigeration cycle to move heat either to or from a heat sink which is typically a large coil of PEX pipe burried in the ground.  Wells, ponds and other sources can be used also.  The idea is that using the ground (or other source), which is a constant temperature of around 50 degrees F, a heat pump can be much more efficient than using resistance heating.

GSHPs are rated by a coefficient of performance, known as COP.  This is a comparison of the amount of electricity used by the heat pump vs. electricity used in resistance heating.  Thus a COP of 5 means the heat pump is producing 5 KW of heat for 1 KW of electric used.  The highest COP is about 6, or 600% efficiency compared to electric resistance heating. A COP of 5 is considered very good.

The electrical distribution system in the US is about 31.2% efficient.  Therefore, a head to head comparison of power used vs. heat produced would look something like this:

1 kWh = 3413 BTU

A GSHP using 1 kWh of electric with a COP of 5 produces 17,065 BTU heat.

The electric plant producing the current to run the GSHP burned 10,939 BTU of fuel to produce 1 kWh.  Therefore, a very well designed, well installed GSHP is about 156% efficient when all the energy requirements are considered.

A typical coal stove is about 60-65% efficient, therefore it would require 26,254 BTU to generate 17,065 BTU of usable heat.

Conclusion: A Ground Source Heat Pump ≠ a coal stove.  GSHPs are energy efficient and a good way to heat a home where solar resources are not available.  They are not 500% efficient, as some companies would have you believe, but are greater than 100% efficient if properly designed and installed.

Tags: , ,

03 Jan 09 | Conservation, Environment, Geothermal
«
»


Reader's Comments

  1. William Swigart | January 5th, 2009 at 3:10 pm

    You mention heating systems that are about maximum 600% efficient, but I found where to look at various systems and their individual approximate efficiencies be that 400%, 500% or at the most 600%. Could you post and direct us where to research that information please?

  2. Paul Thurst | January 5th, 2009 at 3:35 pm

    Here, try this one:

    http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/consumer/your_home/space_heating_cooling/index.cfm/mytopic=12640

  3. Todd | January 8th, 2009 at 12:13 pm

    Very nice simple comparison! As usual you make complicated issues easy to understand.

  4. The Best Heat Pump Systems | January 15th, 2009 at 8:29 am

    Nice article :D

  5. Solar Heating | January 24th, 2009 at 6:15 pm

    I’d have to agree with Todd, you make a lot of sense.

    Very good article, keep it up please and I’ll keep reading :)

  6. Tony | June 10th, 2009 at 6:43 pm

    Makes a lot of sense, I’ll keep my eye out for other stuff by you.I got a library section on my site, maybe I could use this?

  7. Chuck | September 3rd, 2009 at 12:02 am

    That is a great article. Thank you for sharing.

  8. heat pump systems | January 27th, 2010 at 11:18 am

    This is a very good article about heat pumps.



Leave a Reply